BS"D
LONGITUDINAL LENS:
PESACH I
Shira Smiles shiur 2022/5782
Adapted by Channie Koplowitz Stein
When
both the beginning and the end of a work refer to the same idea, we can be
assured that this will be a recurring theme throughout the work being studied
or performed. The example most often cited is that the Torah itself begins and
ends with an act of chesed. Almost at the very beginning of the Torah, Hashem
provides Adam and Chavah with special clothing and dresses them, and the Torah
ends with an act of chesed, with Hashem "personally" burying Moshe
Rabbenu. Thus, a major theme of the entire Torah must be to teach us that we
must emulate Hakodosh Boruch Hu and make chesed a mainstay of our own lives.
This
model holds true for the Seder as well. We begin the Seder with "Ha
lachma anya/This is the bread of affliction," a paragraph that
concludes with "Next Year in the Land of Israel," and we conclude the
Seder with "Next year in Yerushalayim." We will try to trace this
theme as it appears throughout the Haggadah.
Although
authorship of the formalized, liturgical Haggadah is variously attributed to
Rav Yehudah Hanassi, Rav Saadia Gaon, and others, the mitzvah of retelling the
events of the exodus are Torah mandated, and the original source for our
currently accepted general outline dates back to Eliyahu Hanavi himself.
In Maggid Harakiya, Rabbi Glatstein develops this idea, by citing Targum
Yonasan on Exodus 4:13. Hashem has been persistent in asking Moshe
to take Bnei Yisroel out of Egypt. Moshe's final deferral asks Hashem,
"Please send the one you will send." Targum Yonasan suggests
that Moshe wants Hashem to send Pinchas, later identified as Eliyahu, who is
destined to be the harbinger of the final redemption. Pinchas/Eliyahu is
thereby connected to our first redemption from Egypt as well as to our final
redemption at the end of days, the entire span of which is covered in the
Haggadah.
All
the wonders and miracles that Hashem performed in Mitzrayim had a dual purpose,
to punish Mitzrayim while at the same time healing Yisroel. This same dual
purpose continues throughout the generations, writes Rabbi Baum in Lailah
Kayom Yair. Egypt is the paradigm for all our diasporas. The Torah alludes
to all these diasporas when it recounts the names of all that be'im/come
to Mitzrayim. "Come" to Egypt is an unusual word. The Torah usually
writes "descended" to Egypt. However BE'IM is an
acronym for the four diasporas our nation has suffered and continues to suffer,
Babylon, Edom/Rome, (I)Yavan/Greece and Medea/Persia.
Our history is a continuation of the Mitzrayim story, and therefore, as we keep
retelling it, we grow the seed planted in Egypt to create energy for the future
redemption. Therefore, all who increase their involvement in retelling and
re-experiencing the story of the exodus is praiseworthy, for, by so doing, he
is hastening the future redemption and actualizing this hidden potential.
Rabbi
Baum is amazed at the liturgy's multiple numerical calculations describing how
many plagues the Egyptians suffered, each great Sage increasing the number.
Rabbi Baum then deduces that when adding all the numbers together, one arrives
at a total of 613, indicating that just as the 613 mitzvoth of the Torah are
eternal, so too are these plagues to be visited on our enemies at the end of
time.
[Breakdown
as per the Haggadah and Rabbi Baum's interpretation: 10 original plagues + 3
acronym "signs" + a total of 60 of Rabbi Yossi Haglili + a total of
240 of Rabbi Eliezer + a total of 300 of Rabbi Akiva = 613. Each
"total" includes the computation of the plagues in Mitzrayim plus
those at the Sea, according to the multiple of each Sage's interpretation.]
Rabbi
Glatstein cites the Ramban in reminding us that a physical action or material
entity is often used to concretize an esoteric message. Along these lines, all
the symbols of the Seder are meant to symbolize past redemptions and actualize
our future redemption. In this vein, the Seder itself is divided into two
halves, the first half focusing on our redemption from Egypt, while the second
half focuses on our future redemption. When we display and use these symbols of
the past during out Seder, we are simultaneously creating energy to destroy our
future enemies and hasten the redemption.
We
know that the Haggadah is meant to reinforce our faith in Hashem, in the One
God, that it was He alone Who took us out of Egypt. To that end, Moshe's name
does not appear in the Haggadah except one time, that Bnei Yisroel believed in
Hashem and that Moshe was Hashem's servant. The Klausenberger Rebbe clarifies
this point. The Torah tells us that Hashem heard the cries of Bnei
Yisroel and God "knew." Where was Moshe when Hashem chose to
act? He was not in Egypt at all. Moshe was in Midyan shepherding the flocks of
his father-in-law Yisro. As such, Moshe was not even leading Bnei Yisroel in
the prayers that Hashem heard. Today we may feel isolated, without proper
leadership, but we still have the ability to storm the heavens with our
prayers. Hashem hears. And on the night of the Seder, the Night of Watching,
our prayers are extremely powerful.
The
Seder itself constitutes an actual prayer, writes Rabbi Schorr in Halekach
Vehalebuv. If we go through the Haggadah and count the number of blessings
we recite in the course of the Seder, we will note that we recite eighteen
blessings, the same number as in each of the three major daily prayers. We
continue to pray, for we know that we can rely on no earthly leader. Only
Hakodosh Boruch Hu will always be our Rock and Support. When we do our Passover
cleaning, we must rid ourselves not just of the unacceptable and forbidden
chametz that surrounds us in our home, but also of the unacceptable materialism
that inhabits our hearts. Our Sages tell us that while Moshiach can come at any
time, the most likely time is in the month of Nisan, for then our prayers are
extremely powerful.
Rabbi
Mattisyahu Salomon notes that a major theme interwoven with the past and future
redemptions is the theme of emunah/faith. As is written in the prophecy
of Hosea, Hashem says, "I have betrothed thee to me with faith." We
were and will be redeemed through our faith. While it is hard to believe in
that which one has not experienced, we have our history as proof that Hashem
keeps His promises to us. We have survived Purim, we have survived the
Holocaust, and we study the exodus from Egypt. For the miracles of the future
redemption will be even greater than those Hashem promised our forefather
Avraham, that He would judge the nations that oppress us. History has proven
that Hashem is constantly involved in our lives. Do we anticipate and long for
that redemption? Do we notice the sometimes subtle signs of Hashem's presence
and providence? The very first of the Ten Utterances at Sinai was the command
to believe in the God Who took us out of Egypt. When I retell the story of the
exodus, I must have faith that Hashem will redeem us soon, and I must prepare
for that redemption. Every year, the negative energy ebbs and the positive
energy grows stronger.
We
are told that in the merit of righteous women Bnei Yisroel were redeemed from
Mitzrayim. From where did the women of the generation of enslavement derive
righteousness, their ability to withstand the licentiousness of Egyptian
culture? From our Matriarchs. As the Shelah Hakodesh points out, the four cups
of wine represent our four matriarchs.
According
to the Yerushalmi, the four cups also represent the four poisonous cups
of retribution Hashem will foist upon our enemies. Within the recitation of the
various interpretations of the Ten Plagues, we recite the symbolic
manifestations of these plagues, as found in Joel; "Blood, and Fire, and
Clouds of Smoke." As we say each of these phrases, we remove a drop of red
wine from our cup, for each represents the calamities that will befall our
enemies in the future. Just as we remove a drop of wine with the recitation of
each of the plagues of Egypt, here, too, we limit our rejoicing at the fall of
our enemies who are also God's creatures.
Rabbi
Dovid Altshuler, the Metsudos Dovid, who lived in the mid 1700's gave a
chillingly prescient interpretation to these phrases: Dam/Blood refers
to the blood that will be spilled in battles on land; Aish/Fire from the
sky; Timrot (Tamar) Ashan/Clouds shaped like palm trees [mushroom
clouds].
As
we pick up our cups and cover the matzoh to recite the paragraph of "Vehi
Sheomdah/That which has sustained us...," we refocus on the promise
Hashem made to our forefather. Although every generation has brought those who
would annihilate us, the promise Hashem made to Avraham, to redeem his progeny,
remains in place for every generation, for each subsequent exile is but a
branch of the tree of our first exile in Egypt, writes Rabbi Bernstein.
Rabbi
Frand builds on this idea. Starting with the Baal Haturim and continuing
to the Reisher Rav, Rabbi Frand traces the connection between the only four
verses that begin with, "Atem.../You..." These four verses
show Hashem's involvement in our protection throughout history, From Pharaoh's
telling us, "You [Bnei Yisroel] get for yourselves straw...,"
continuing to the plagues, "You saw," leading to the purpose of the
redemption, "You are standing today before God," to recognizing
Hashem's hidden providence, "You are My witnesses," the four verses
present a progression that brings us to the cup of Elijah and to the final,
fourth cup, the cup of our future redemption.
As
we conclude the first half of the Seder and recite the blessing over the second
cup of wine, we pray that Hashem will bring us to "holidays and festivals haboim
likrateinu/that come toward us in peace." Rabbi Bernstein questions
this unusual turn of phrase. He suggests that this terminology refers to the
two different ways the final redemption will come; Either it will come at its
predesignated time, or, through our righteousness, we will merit its coming
earlier. If our deeds bring that time closer, it will come in peace. Otherwise,
the times will be traumatic. We believe in that ultimate redemption, and we
pour a cup for Eliyahu who wrote the Haggadah and who will announce and herald
that time.
We
continue with liturgical poems that recount all the historical events that took
place on this Seder night, and we pray that the day will come that will
transform night into day. Among the miracles of this night are two that refer
to Lot. The first was when Avraham Avinu rescued him in the war of the four
kings against the five, and the second was when he and his daughters were saved
from the destruction of Sodom. As we anticipate the final redemption, we
recall the miracles that saved Lot, the ancestor through his daughters, of King
David and Moshiach, writes Rabbi Kluger.
Ruth
herself, great-grandmother of David, is alluded to in a symbol of the Seder,
continues Rabbi Kluger. The charoset is an
anagram of chas Rut/Ruth had compassion, while Orpah,
who turned her back of Naomi and the Jewish people, is an anagram of Pharaoh.
The bitterness of Orpah, grandmother of Goliath, will be defeated by David, who
will sing sweet songs to Hashem, and balance out the bitterness and negativity
of the world, as the blood-red of wine is sweetened by the charoset.
While
the redemption took place in just one day, in an instant, we are commanded to
remember it all the days of our life. The seeds of every salvation in our
history were planted on that day, we get glimpses of it from time to time, and
by re-enacting those events at the Seder, we are reinforcing our faith in a leil
shimurim/night of watchfulness [ours and Hashem's] and hastening the
arrival of Moshiach Tzidkeinu.