RECOGNITION, RESPECT AND REPENTANCE: PARSHAT
ZACHOR
Shira Smiles shiur 2016/5776
Summary by Channie Koplowitz Stein
It is well known that the Maftir, the special final portion of Torah
reading, for the Shabbat before Purim recounts the perfidy of Amalek’s
attacking Bnei Yisroel as Bnei Yisroel left Egypt in a weakened state. Because
this selection begins with the word zachor – remember-, the Shabbat
itself is called Shabbat Zachor, We are exhorted to remember what Amalek
did to us specifically at this time because Haman, the villain of the Purim
narrative, is a descendant of Amalek. The Tosher Rebbe raises an interesting
question in Avodat Avodah. Given this reasoning, would it not be more
appropriate to read this selection on Purim itself rather than on the Shabbat
preceding Purim? Further, why read this selection that recounts the attack at
the end of the forty years in the desert and our obligation to remember it and
annihilate Amalek rather than the original narrative at the time it happened?
Rav Reiss quoting Chazal offers one response for the timing of this reading.
Since the Megillah itself tells us that the Purim events are to be remembered
and observed, and remembrance precedes observation of the holiday, he reasons
that we must remember the events on the Shabbos preceding Purim through reading
the story of Amalek, the nation of Haman. Rav Reiss then continues to explain
why the remembrance should be specifically on Shabbat. Notice the similarity in
language, he writes: Compare, “Remember that which Amalek did to
you….that he happened upon you on the way,” with, “Remember
the Sabbath Day and make it holy.” Since Shabbat is a day dedicated to
remembrance, there must be some significance in juxtaposing these two commands,
and there must be something special about Shabbat that counters Amalek.
This question can be examined through the three aspects the Maharal identifies
as the three dimensions of all existence: Relationship to God, relationship to
others, and relationship to self.
The Shem MiShmuel discusses the idea presented by Pirkei D’Rabbi
Eliezer, that Amalek is the opposite of Shabbos. How? Let us begin by
understanding the two aspects that Shabbat represents, as recited in the Kiddush.
After creation, it was Shabbat that first imbued the physical world with
sanctity. Then the exodus revealed Hashem’s presence in this world and His
ability to harness all the physical world to do His bidding. All the nations of
the world trembled and acknowledged Hashem, save for Amalek. Amalek’s
philosophy consisted of denying God by creating doubt about His existence, by
asserting that everything was happenstance and coincidence, asher korcha
baderech- who “happened” upon you on the way, rather than that the
exodus and all its associated miracles were coordinated by God. Their related
mission was to defile Bnei Yisroel so they would no longer be sanctified. Every
week as we observe Shabbat, we counter the influence of Amalek and its
philosophy. Therefore, it is appropriate that we read about Amalek on the
Shabbat before Purim.
But, as Rabbi Reiss notes, Hashem finely coordinated even the timing of
Amalek’s attack. Bnei Yisroel, after Moshe got water from the rock, had
verbalized, “Is Hashem actually within us or not?” This doubt came right after
Hashem provided the manna for Bnei Yisroel including instructions not to go out
to collect the manna on Shabbat. Nevertheless, some of Bnei Yisroel challenged
Hashem and went out to collect the manna on Shabbat morning, but there was
none, again proving that Hashem was in control. Immediately, Amalek, whose very
name equals doubt in Hebrew numerology, came as if to prove that Hashem was
there and heard their lapse in faith. (Amalek=240=safek.)
The timing of Amalek’s attack proves not only that Hashem exists, but also that
He controls the world at every moment.
Shabbat provides the seal to that truth. When I refrain from working on
Shabbat, I am testifying that Hashem provides all my needs, as He did during
the forty years in the desert. Our three Shabbat meals bear further witness to
this belief, writes Mesilot Beohr Hachasidut, of the Belzer dynasty.
There is a custom to lift up one’s hands after washing for bread, as if being
ready to receive the manna directly from heaven. By affirming my faith through
Shabbat observance, writes the Slonimer Rebbe in Netivot Shalom, I am
countering the doubt that Amalek tried to instill in Bnei Yisroel. When we tap
into Shabbat fully, we access the two pillars of all 613 commandments, emunah
and kedushah, faith and sanctity, and we break the shell of Amalek. As
Rabbi Boruch Leff notes, we are commanded to erase the memory of Amalek from
under the heaven. But on Shabbat we are lifted above the heavens where Amalek
does not exist. Further, we no longer know who Amalek is, but if we strive to
eliminate negativity and doubt from our lives, as we should do on Shabbat, we
are shutting out the evil forces that Amalek represents.
We read Parshat Zachor twice during the year, once as part of the regular Torah
reading thirty days before Yom Kippur and again on this special Shabbat, thirty
days before Pesach, notes the Gerrer Rebbe. Reading About Amalek on these two
Shabbatot helps arouse us to focus on eradicating the evil of Amalek as we
enter these holy seasons. The mitzvah of Purim needs the added kedushah
that Shabbat brings. This Shabbat is one of the holiest of the year, as it
brings together both mitzvoth of Shabbat, zachor – remember and shamor
– observe.
A further aspect of Purim is the command to give gifts to the poor. Our Rabbis
extrapolate from this that on this day we should give to anyone who stretches
out his hand to ask for a donation. We are not to question or ask for proof of
his worthiness. Similarly, on Purim, we too can ask Hashem for anything,
especially spiritual requests for ourselves and our children, and Hashem will
respond favorably. But, writes the Netivot Shalom, we need to be able to
stretch out our hand and ask for that help. On this Shabbat, Hashem is
stretching out His hand (so to speak), urging us to stretch out ours and ask
for His help in difficult situations. While Purim awakens us from below,
Shabbat awakens us with the desire to elevate ourselves from below. In this
respect, Shabbat Zachor is even greater than Purim as we begin the process of
countering the effects of Amalek. This Shabbat acts as a catalyst for the
fulfillment of Purim. In fact, the final redemption will come only through the
power of truth when all lies, represented by Amalek, are eradicated, writes the
Tosher Rebbe.
Rabbi Zev Leff continues with an assessment of the world today. We live in a
world of falsehood. When people lie, nature itself seems to follow suit. Clouds
form, but no rain comes. We wear clothes made of synthetic materials and eat
food produced from synthetic ingredients, like fruit juice with no fruit. We’ve
even learned to create lying pictures with Photo shop. We have to focus on
always being truthful and instilling in our children the value of truth. That
is how we counter the falsity of Amalek. After all, writes the Tosher Rebbe,
Amalek inherited and learned how to lie from his grandfather Esau, who know how
to “hunt with his mouth”, whereas Yaakov was innocent and flawless, and studied
constantly.
There is a difference between sheker, falsity through lies, and shav,
falsity through meaninglessness. The one who uses lies to manipulate people
still recognizes that what he’s doing and saying is wrong. But the one who
falsifies using shav has lost the distinction between right and wrong,
between truth and untruth, and will justify everything he says. [In a public
high school class discussion, one of my students justified a drug dealer’s
profits because “he faces so many risks.”c.k.s.] In other words, he has become
indifferent and cold, kar, to honesty and truth. He no longer looks even
at himself honestly.
What brings a person to this condition? The Tosher Rebbe continues. It is
nothing more than haughtiness and arrogance. It is the feeling that I am always
right, and nothing else matters but what I think or I want. When I can consider
my fallibility and the possibility that I am wrong, I can examine other
people’s ideas honestly and admit if I am wrong. I can view what others have
without feelings of jealousy and entitlement, for I can acknowledge that their
needs differ from mine, and I have all my needs. Our challenge, highlighted on
Purim, is to be able to give to others with joy, as signified by the special
Purim mitzvoth of mishloach manot and gifts to the poor.
But one can be “charitable” toward others in ways that will keep us humble.
Shabbat Zachor especially is all about connection, to respect and value
yourself as well as others, to see something special in every human being, and
to find something we can learn from the other person’s character, demeanor, or
actions.
Ultimately, our connection to others leads to a closer connection to Hakodosh
Boruch Hu Who has sanctified us through the Shabbos. This connection and
complete reliance on Him brings us to complete joy. Therefore, those who
observe Shabbat fully experience complete joy in Hashem’s sovereignty, a joy
that is renewed each Shabbos as we find ourselves fulfilled. As such, Shabbat
is a special gift from Hashem Who supplied the manna in the desert to each
according to his need. In the desert, each could sit in his tent on Shabbat,
and he would have all he needed, for Hashem had supplied it all daily and
doubly before Shabbat. No one went out to compare what he had to what others
had. Each was content in his own tent realizing that Hashem had provided him
with all his needs.
The Tosher Rebbe finds a method of reconnecting to Hashem in the listing of
Mordechai’s genealogy. He is the son of Yair (brings light), the
son of Shimi (Who hears), the son of Kish (to batter open, knock
down). Mordechai enlightened the eyes of Bnei Yisroel through prayer, then
Hashem heard them, and then Bnei Yisroel stormed the heavenly gates of mercy.
This was in fact the order of Mordechai and Esther’s interaction with Bnei
Yisroel. First Mordechai had to awaken Bnei Yisroel from their complacency,
from their enjoyment of Ahashuerosh’s party. When they realized how badly they
had sinned, Hashem would begin listening to them and they could storm the gates
of mercy to reverse a decree that had already been written in cement. This is
in fact what we must do to vanquish the Amalek within ourselves. We must recognize
the negativity and sins within ourselves so that Hashem will listen to us as we
entreat Him to open the gates of mercy. We must take the first step, and become
vessels where the light of holiness can enter.
Shabbos is the beginning of this process. If we look closely, we will note that
the letters of Shabbat are the root teshuvah, return, return to your
Source, to Hakodosh Boruch Hu, writes Rabbi Boruch Leff, for Shabbat is the
starting point for all that is called holy.
Along these line, the Belzer Rebbe notes that the Shabbat before Yom Kippur is
called Shabbat
Shuva,
or we are admonished to return to Hashem before that awesome day. Similarly,
the Shabbat before Purim should also signify a return and repentance, a time
for introspection so that I make my Shabbat as spiritual and holy as I can, and
remove all vestiges of Amalek from my life. After all, the Gemarra says that
Yom Hakipurim is actually a day (yom) like (k) Purim.
Shabbat Zachor is a day when we recognize Hashem’s sovereignty, which leads us
to respect ourselves and others, and brings us to repentance. May Hashem again
extricate us from the falsehood of Amalek that surrounds us so that all the
world will again recognize His sovereignty.